Top Gacha Games Ranked by Pull Value and Pity System
Not all gacha games are created equal. While flashy animations and limited banners may grab your attention, what really matters is how far your pulls go. Some games give you real value with transparent pity systems and decent rates — others feel more like slot machines.
This guide breaks down the best gacha games based on pull efficiency, factoring in:
- Base drop rates
- Soft and hard pity
- Rate-up guarantees
- Currency cost per pull
- Banner design and fairness
Whether you’re a meta-chaser, a F2P planner, or just tired of rolling endlessly with nothing to show for it, this list is your shortcut to smarter summons.
1. Honkai: Star Rail & Genshin Impact (Hoyoverse)
Base 5★ drop rate: 0.6%
Soft pity: ~74
Hard pity: 90
Rate-up guarantee: Yes, after losing 50/50
Cost per pull: 160 Primogems / Stellar Jades
Hoyoverse titles are industry leaders when it comes to predictable, transparent gacha systems. You’ll rarely feel completely scammed, even when you miss your 5★. The pity system is aggressive enough that you’re almost guaranteed a hit within 80–90 pulls, and the 50/50 mechanic with guaranteed next-pull rate-up makes planning for characters or weapons manageable — especially for F2P players.
Their weakness? Weapon banners. But if you’re mostly pulling on character banners, the math is on your side.
2. Blue Archive
Base 3★ (top rarity) drop rate: 3%
Soft pity: ~180
Hard pity: 200
Rate-up guarantee: Yes
Cost per pull: 120 Pyroxene
Blue Archive gets overlooked, but it offers one of the fairest long-term pity systems out there. While the number of pulls required for hard pity is high, you don’t lose progress when you miss rate-up units. The spark system lets you redeem the featured character after 200 pulls no matter what.
It’s F2P-friendly, particularly if you save up Pyroxene or focus on specific banners. The community praises it for low burnout and generous compensation events. Add solid 3★ rates and you’ve got a system that actually respects your time.
3. Fate/Grand Order (FGO)
Base 5★ drop rate: 1%
Soft pity: None
Hard pity: 330
Rate-up guarantee: No
Cost per pull: 3 Saint Quartz
FGO is infamous for its brutal gacha, but it earns a spot here for transparency and consistency. Until recently, it had no pity system at all, but the introduction of a 330-pull hard pity for some banners was a welcome change. That said, there’s no rate-up guarantee, so missing a banner unit is still very possible.
Pulling in FGO is a high-risk, high-emotion experience — but at least the math is now trackable, and Saint Quartz comes regularly if you’re active.
4. Arknights
Base 6★ drop rate: 2%
Soft pity: ~50
Hard pity: 99
Rate-up guarantee: Yes
Cost per pull: 600 Orundum
Arknights is a sleeper hit for gacha value. With a high base rate of 2% and a pity system that ramps hard after 50 pulls, it’s one of the more forgiving games for getting top-tier units. Dupes matter less, and new operators are rarely mandatory, reducing banner FOMO.
The rate-up guarantee is also clean — you get the featured operator on your second 6★ if you miss the first. It’s not flashy, but it’s honest.
5. Wuthering Waves
Base 5★ drop rate: 0.8%
Soft pity: ~75
Hard pity: 80
Rate-up guarantee: Yes, after 50/50
Cost per pull: 160 Lustrous Tide
As one of the newest gacha games on the scene, Wuthering Waves surprised many by adopting a player-friendly system right out of the gate. The hard pity is one of the lowest in the industry at just 80 pulls, and you’re guaranteed the rate-up on the second hit.
It feels like a love letter to Genshin fans who want something slightly more generous. If they keep this model and don’t add complex weapon banner traps, it could be a major contender long-term.
Honorable Mention: Nikke
Base SSR drop rate: 4%
Soft pity: 40
Hard pity: 200
Rate-up guarantee: Yes
Cost per pull: 300 Gems
While technically a different beast due to its shooter mechanics, Nikke has one of the most generous SSR rates on this list and a robust pity system. That said, power creep and dupe requirements make the economy a bit deceptive.
If you’re looking for constant dopamine hits, this is a great casual grinder — but not the best for long-term planning.
How We Ranked These Gacha Systems
This list focuses on pull value per premium currency, not just generosity or game quality. Games were scored across five dimensions:
- Base drop rate for highest rarity
- Soft and hard pity timing
- Presence and quality of rate-up guarantee
- How forgiving the system is for unlucky players
- Transparency and banner design
We excluded games that:
- Don’t have real pity systems
- Are no longer active
- Or rely heavily on paid-only mechanics
Want to Go Deeper?
We break down how pity systems, 50/50 mechanics, and rate-up guarantees actually work in our myth-busting guide.
Or for a look at the behavioral tricks these systems use to keep players pulling, check out the psychology of gacha.
Get the Math Behind the Rankings
Curious how many pulls you need to hit soft pity in your favorite game? Want to compare drop rates or simulate your odds at getting a rate-up character?
Use Gacha Calculator — the web’s cleanest gacha probability calculator — to simulate your chances across dozens of banners.